UTICA – The man accused of murdering Thomas Shepherd in Rome this summer turned down a plea deal in Oneida County Court this morning.
Robert Coffin, 35, is charged with second-degree murder and second-degree criminal possession of a weapon. He’s accused of shooting 25-year-old Thomas Shepherd Jr. to death outside of Sammy G’s bar on August 19. Authorities say that on that night, Coffin and Shepherd were involved in a dispute in the parking lot of Sammy G’s bar before Coffin shot Shepherd twice in the head, then fled the scene.
Coffin eluded police for nearly two weeks before being found in Las Vegas, and he was brought back to Oneida County and into Rome police custody last month.
In Oneida County Court today, Coffin turned down a plea deal that would have given him 23 years to life in state prison for pleading guilty to second-degree murder.
“I’m not pleading guilty to murder,” Coffin said. “It’s something I’m not guilty of.”
Coffin will now be headed to trial, and it's unknown at this time when that will start.
- Man accused of August murder in Rome turns down plea deal
- Rome murder suspect Coffin rejects plea offer
- Plea deal offered to Laurens man accused of killing parents
- Man accused of Rome murder appears in court
- Rome man accused of raping female child
- Rome man accused of raping child
- Rome man accused of raping female victim
- Utica man accused of stabbing man to death receives plea deal
- Still no decision on plea deal for Utica man accused of killing baby
- Man accused of threatening Utica College asks for more time to consider plea deal