Opening arguments in trial of cue ball murder trial

Tools

Opening arguments in trial of cue ball murder trial

UTICA - The trial has begun for two men accused of beating a Rome man to death at a party in Westmoreland last summer. The prosecution and defense delivered their opening arguments today.

On trial are Bradley Stanistreet and Kevin Stolarcyk. They are facing charges of manslaughter and gang assault. The prosecution says the two men, along with others, attacked Carl Hill on the night of August 12, and that the attack ultimately lead to his death.

Jurors heard three opening arguments today - one from the prosecution and two from the defense. Each defendant has their own lawyer, but there is only one jury hearing the case.

All three attorneys described the events they believe happened leading up to a massive fight that is said to have broken out at a house party in Camelot Village in Westmoreland.

Each shared with the jurors the types of witnesses they plan to call to the stand, and how those witnesses will help them prove the guilt or innocence of Stanistreet and Stolarcyk.

One theme that kept recurring in the opening arguments - the rivalry between the Rome and Westmoreland kids.

"All over a simple matter as one group one young people live across the border of the City of Rome and the other lived in the Town of Westmoreland and that's about it which really makes it a tragedy," said Timothy Fitzgerald, Assistant District Attorney.

On the defense side - both lawyers argued that given the time and nature of the scene when the fight broke out - it might be difficult for the prosecution to prove exactly what happened.

"Nobody is going to be able to explain to you in detail or with any degree of accuracy what was going on who was hitting who who was getting knocked down with any degree of accuracy," said Les Lewis, defense attorney for Stanistreet.

"You'll hear that some of these people if not most of them were at various levels of intoxication at this time this incident occurred between 2 and 4 in the morning and some of these people had been drinking all night," said Mark Wolber, defense attorney for Stolarcyk."So that may have impacted their ability to recall what they're going to be testifying about."

Testimony will begin Tuesday morning at 9:30. It is expected that at some point throughout the trial both defendents will be taking the stand.

View comments

The following comments do not necessarily represent the views of NBC-WKTV News Channel 2. Users have agreed to these terms and in doing so accept full responsibility for their comments. Moderation is limited.

Saturday, May 17 at 5:12 PM To March 4 unknown wrote ...

I was just going back reading these and yours stuck out. Do you know these boys? Do you know what was really going on that night? If you don't then you have NO right calling them sick and from a bad seed?? I can't say what I really would like to say to you. God Bless you and forgive you for your thoughts

3956889 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Mar 7 at 5:05 PM media wrote ...

MEDIA needs to make it clear that Brad's charge of manslaughter has been dropped!!! He did not hit Hill with a pool ball, he punshed him and he is doing time for that

2539332 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Mar 7 at 12:11 AM everyone wrote ...

has anyone on here been to court to listen to what is actually being said, instead of reading it in the paper, or getting their info from the news? Today cleared everything up he died from one hit from that cueball. no mistake about that. Besides that there are more people out there guilty than just those 4 guys. Do the two on trial deserve 25 years no they don't, did john almana deserve 5yrs no he didn't. Cory hit him w/the cueball he was the only one to use that weapon he deserves 25yrs.

2526752 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Mar 6 at 10:30 AM dana wrote ...

this is in response to: "7:08 PM friend of john and cory wrote ... you all act like you've never gone to a party and had problems wit someone. you all act like you've never fought." No I have never fought. That is not how I was brought up. I was brought up to turn the other cheek...... Maybe kids these days need to be taught that. And I am not much older than them I am 28 They should have been taught that as well. then there would not be a life taken. THey deserve what they get.25 yrs to life

2513271 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Mar 5 at 8:08 PM friend of john and cory wrote ...

you all act like you've never gone to a party and had problems wit someone. you all act like you've never fought. this fight went to far yes. but lets keep putting them down? no. they're payin a price for being at the party. so chill out

2506671 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Mar 5 at 1:57 AM MAD wrote ...

NEXT TIME YOU HAVE SOMEONE ADVERTISE FREE CANDY,CHECK OUT THE SPONSOR.THEY ARE TRYING TO GET YOU TO PAY FOR A MONTHLY SERVICE IN A SLICK MANNOR. i THINK ALOT OF PEOPLE ARE GOING TO GET RIPPED OFF. PLEASE PULL ADD.

2493277 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Mar 5 at 12:45 AM I love my little brother!! wrote ...

Rivalry???? Are u serious?? There are bigger things at stake here then Westmoreland's "precious reputation"...lives for one...4 of them to be exact!! But wait I forgot that because they aren't your "perfect" children then it dont much matter right? How silly of me to think all these MEN are family first,not criminals. I will be sure to revise my thought process next time.

2492801 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Mar 5 at 12:07 AM unknown wrote ...

These boys, kids, men- whatever you want to call them are are sick individuals. Anyone that can take life from another does not deserve to be free. How sad that they are only looking at the possiblility that it was just rivaly. Take a good hard look at those men - would you want them hanging around your house -what if they lost their temper with your family members.Sometimes there are just bad seeds - looks like these are all bad seeds..

2492497 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Mar 4 at 9:47 PM Concerned parent wrote ...

I myself went to westmoreland, there was never any rivalry between rome and westmoreland kids. Maybe these few had problems but does that make all westmoreland and rome kids out to get one another? No it doesnt. Both of these boys from westmoreland were always in trouble, and one specifically got away with way to much maybe its time they both learned what lifes really about and its time to grow up..fighting isnt cool. And if they were really "Men" why do they need to fight with pool balls???

2491006 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Mar 4 at 1:50 PM Sad Parent wrote ...

The "rivalry" they are referring to is the very same "rivalry" that coaches and parents push on these kids as youngsters - better clothing, better birthday parties, better grades and most of all better sports teams. Our entire childhoods are filled with competition and now, with a growing population of parents who are trying to be friends with their kids instead of parenting, things are getting out of control. Kids are attacking eachother and law enforcement. I'm sad for my small child's future.

2484051 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Mar 4 at 9:36 AM I agree wrote ...

I completely agree with concerned parent. I am proud to say that I am from Westmoreland. I have went to Westmoreland for 10 years and graduated from there and for how long I was there I have never had a rivilary with rome kids. None what so ever! It is very offensive because you are giving westmoreland a bad name because a select few made a bad decision. Talking about quick to judge.

2479966 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Mar 4 at 9:34 AM Another concerned citizen wrote ...

Can we drum up so journalistic skills and stop referring to these individuals as 'kids'? If they are being tried as adults, lets refer to them as adults.

2479941 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Mar 4 at 3:29 AM concerned parent & resident wrote ...

there is NO rivilary between the rome-westmoreland kids only a select few from each rome and westmoreland. i keep seeing "the rivilary between the rome and westmoreland kids" so stop trying to make ALL the kids sound bad. i along with other parents take that very offensive by making all our children to sound voilent.

2478571 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

NBC-WKTV News Channel 2 and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

I have read and agree to the terms

Hide comments

Weather

Icon
Current Temp 54.0 °F
Fair
More Weather

AP Video

Stock Quotes

Permanent Client link holder

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

What's On