Attorney: Inmates refer to Auchmoody as "Father Time"; he insists no knowledge of severity of mother's condition

Tools

Attorney: Inmates refer to Auchmoody as "Father Time"; he insists no knowledge of severity of mother's condition

By JOLEEN FERRIS

UTICA - A Whitestown man was sentenced Friday for his role in his elderly mother's death. David Auchmoody pleaded guilty to criminally negligent homicide in the death last year of Edith Auchmoody.

But he walked off to prison insisting that he just didn't know that his mother was in such bad shape.

His lawyer says people in jail refer to David Auchmoody as "Father Time." Attorney Christopher Pelli received letters in support of Auchmoody, one from a nearly 90 year old man who quoted former U.S. Supreme Court Justice William O. Douglas

"The right to be let alone is indeed the beginning of all freedoms," Pelli said.

"I want to let everybody understand that I loved my mother very much," Auchmoody told the court.

And David Auchmoody says he was just carrying out his mother's wishes to die at home and without the care of strangers. But when funeral home employees came to the Auchmoody's home in Whitestown to remove Edith Auchmoody's body, they called authorities.

She had wasted away to nearly nothing - exposed flesh from severe bedsores covered much of her barely 50 pound frame.

At his sentencing for criminally negligent homicide, David Auchmoody said he loved his mother but was unqualified to care of her.

"I never knew she had bedsores, let alone infected ones," Auchmoody said. "I have no experience with medicine, medical care, caring for the elderly, nothing; I just thought she was failing naturally."

The judge said that David Auchmoody's crime was one of omission, not commission. but a crime nonetheless.

"But I also can't get past the fact that any human being with their eyes wide open couldn't have seen that your mother was suffering," said Judge Barry Donalty.

For his plea to criminally negligent homicide, David Auchmoody will spend the next 1 1/3 - 4 years in prison.

View comments

The following comments do not necessarily represent the views of NBC-WKTV News Channel 2. Users have agreed to these terms and in doing so accept full responsibility for their comments. Moderation is limited.

Monday, May 26 at 10:47 AM Let's free this man wrote ...

He appears to need some medical/mental health care. Prison is not the answer for everyone. Look to the womsns doctor and put charges against him/her, for the dealth, not this man who is so sad looking. May God be with you David.

Flag for moderation

Sunday, May 25 at 10:07 PM Caregiver to parent wrote ...

I agree with the above "concerned nurse." There are many agencies out there and her doctor or some health care professional should have gotten them information on such or even made the arrangements, if the son could not do it himself. It is not his fault. I do not believe he knowingly let her suffer.

Flag for moderation

Sunday, May 25 at 7:40 PM emt wrote ...

Maybe we need a "right to peace" document, like a DNR, to sign before we get this old, to exonerate our relatives who follow our wishes. Honor thy father and mother , by respecting their wishes. Senator Clinton would have put the woman in a state run nursing home and let her be a guinea pig instead. rest in peace and free her son.

Flag for moderation

Saturday, May 24 at 11:17 PM Christi wrote ...

The problem here is another problem that is becoming more and more prevelent as time goes by. There is no privacy anymore, No right to raise your children or care for your parents the way you or they see fit. Who has the right to tell this woman what to do? Not one person. She had a phone, and if she needed help she would have asked. It's big brother in our homes, raising our kids and now telling us what to think. This whole thing is disgusting and the DA should have kept out of this.

Flag for moderation

Saturday, May 24 at 9:20 PM Christi wrote ...

This was not a murder! This was a son who gave his mother exactly what she asked of him. No one can ever be in his shoes and the fact that she expressed her wishes to be left alone and die naturally, should have been honored, which is what he did. I bet she is rolling over in her grave seeing her son in jail for making sure her wishes were kept. I know a lot of elderly people who live with their children and they will not allow them to tend to their needs. So, who's next. Its going to repeat.

Flag for moderation

Saturday, May 24 at 8:29 PM me wrote ...

No man wants to strip his mom and look at her back end. And I'm sure she didn't complain if she wanted to be left alone. Sure he 'should' have called someone else for advice, but other people could have also intervened. Maybe this woman really wanted to die on her own terms! Not by being drugged or wiped by a stranger. Did anyone check if he is mentally stable? I'm sure if he was, he isn't now.

Flag for moderation

Saturday, May 24 at 8:38 AM IMO wrote ...

The guy is obviously not wrapped tightly. He didn't have the wherewithall to move out of his mother's house and have his own life. I bet ya, if you put him in his own home, he'd deteriorate and decompensate medically, as well as, live in the filth that his mother was living in. Institutionalization is the best thing. At least there he has to have order in his life. Prison may teach him the basics. Father Time needs to go do his TIME and learn consistency, discipline, and order!

Flag for moderation

Friday, May 23 at 10:27 PM Healthcare Provider wrote ...

Go after the Doctor in charge and then about going after the politicians because we all are wasting away because of the way they run our lives

Flag for moderation

Friday, May 23 at 7:36 PM Anonymous wrote ...

i believe that he thought he was helping her by complying wiuth her wishes

Flag for moderation

Friday, May 23 at 5:45 PM Let he who has not sinned cst the first stone wrote ...

There is a difference between murder and neglect.Granted he should have done the right thing for his mother care regardless of her wishes. He might have some psychological issues of his own that prohibited from understanding the severity of his actions.

Flag for moderation

Friday, May 23 at 4:50 PM Concerned Nurse! wrote ...

I am a healthcare professional and can not rationalize, why if this woman had a debilitating illness and her wishes were to die at home, then why hadnt the physician in charge of her arranged for public health agencies to ensure that her son was capable and able to care for her at home? I know in a hospital setting, these things are done for the elderly with these type of wishes prior to discharge back to the home. I feel the responsibility of this crime lies within the healthcare system itself!

Flag for moderation

Friday, May 23 at 3:21 PM Sad wrote ...

That man murdered his mother and he gets only 1 1/3 - 4 years? What about the years that she took care of him, turn the table, she took care of his for way more than 3 to 4 years? how about 20 to 25 years

Flag for moderation

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

Comments are moderated and will not appear on this story until after they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

NBC-WKTV News Channel 2 and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

I have read and agree to the terms

Hide comments

Weather On Demand

Weather Radar
Icon
Current Temp 48 °F
Partly Cloudy
Wind : From the Southwest at 15 Gusting to 21 MPH
Humidity : 52 %
Pressure : 29.40" (995.8 mb) in.
Wind Chill : 42 °F
More Weather

On Demand

AP Video

Stock Quotes

Permanent Client link holder

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

Viewer Poll

Who do you feel should replace Hillary Clinton as a U.S. Senator?

  • Governor David Paterson
  • Attorney General Andrew Cuomo
  • U.S. Representative Kirsten Gillibrand
  • U.S. Representative Nydia Velazquez
  • Someone else you feel is more qualified

What's On