NYSARC Condemns Film “Tropic Thunder”

NYSARC, Inc., the nation’s largest family based non-profit agency representing persons with intellectual and other developmental disabilities criticized the Dreamworks film “Tropic Thunder” for fostering and encouraging negative stereotypes of persons with intellectual and other developmental disabilities.

The Organization’s President, Katharine Wilson Conroy, stated that “the film goes out of its way to encourage the use of demeaning characterizations of persons with intellectual disabilities. ARC Chapters and its families across New York State have worked for years to help the people they serve realize their rightful place as fully participating members of their community.”

Ms. Conroy further stated “to do this they have had to overcome centuries of culturally ingrained abuse, mistreatment and oppression. Dreamworks ignores this reality. It shows utter contempt for the fact that negative language leads to negative action, not only in the form of rejecting persons with intellectual disabilities but providing an excuse to use them as objects of physical and emotional abuse and ridicule.”

NYSARC’s executive director, Marc N. Brandt, stated that the film “uses the word `retard,’ as if it were harmless amusement and good fun. For the people, parents and families we serve, it is anything but that. We should all remember that similar terms have been used to describe other oppressed persons, devaluing them, making them less than human in the eyes of their fellow citizens and making it all too easy to segregate, exclude, ridicule and, yes, beat and lynch them.”

Dehumanizing people not only devalues them but also cheapens, denigrates and devalues the entire society we live in.”

Ms. Conroy noted that “we are not against free speech rather we are for responsible speech. The images and characterizations employed in Tropic Thunder are oblivious to hundreds of years of the lessons we should have learned about the consequences of demeaning and belittling treatment of specific groups of people.”

NYSARC, Inc. is calling on the motion picture industry, the executives of Dreamworks and everyone associated with this film to put compassion rather than profit first by delaying the release of this film and removing its offensive and harmful material.

This story is inappropriate and should be flagged for moderation. Please choose from one of the following options:

You have indicated this comment should be removed.


The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Pat again says ... on Sunday, Aug 31 at 3:45 PM

Three weeks in a row! And no answer from ARC, perhaps they now know that the portions of the film that they deem as offensive talk about a total of 1/16 of the film's runtime would only be offensive to a fool?

Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Pat McRoch says ... on Monday, Aug 25 at 1:11 PM

Number one movie two weeks in a row! Poor ARC and their misguided attempt at publicity.

Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Has anyone says ... on Sunday, Aug 17 at 12:25 PM

that is protesting even seen the film prior to protesting? Is it understood that the film is mocking Hollywood attitudes toward the everyman and the lengths that some actors will go for an award/recognition? Nah, lets just picket blind!

Inappropriate? Alert Us!

continuing the previous post says ... on Thursday, Aug 14 at 8:27 PM

I would just not watch it. Obviously nothing is going to change. It's good to educate people about it, but ultimately people are going to do what they want and make their own judgments. Hollywood will get the clue when the movie flops.

Inappropriate? Alert Us!

I understand the outrage. says ... on Thursday, Aug 14 at 8:24 PM

I have worked with people with disabilities of all ages. It is tasteless what the movie has done to portray people w/ disabilities. BUT that said, if there was a rally for every single thing we thought offensive, there'd be few movies left to watch..

Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Lynn Klein says ... on Wednesday, Aug 13 at 3:37 PM

I have seen previews in the theater for this film, and no hint of this aspect is given. I believe that might be because someone in the production dept. knew that it wasn't good PR nor would it help bring people to see it. Misleading? Intentional?

Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Laurie Dingman says ... on Wednesday, Aug 13 at 2:18 PM

Right on NYSARC! I am in total support of this public protest and agree totally. They are talking about the people that I serve and are extended family to me.

Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment


Comment: 250 Characters Left

NBC-WKTV News Channel 2 | Utica, NY News, Weather and Sports and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

I have read and agree to the terms