Accountants: Manafort falsified loan documents

Paul Manafort's accountants testified against the former Trump campaign chairman on Friday, telling jurors that loan amounts were fudged to help him on his taxes, loan documents sent to banks were forged and that he did not disclose his foreign accounts.

Posted: Aug 5, 2018 2:51 PM
Updated: Aug 5, 2018 3:20 PM

The fourth day of Paul Manafort's trial blended tax documents with a witness' astonishing confession of guilt. Prosecutors are well into presenting hundreds of documents that they say show bank fraud, failure to disclose foreign bank accounts and tax crimes.

Here are four takeaways from the court action Friday:

1. Bank fraud smoking guns?

In a courtroom, lawyers have various tools to make their points: video screens to show evidence, pointed questions to elicit certain answers and witnesses to speak about their firsthand knowledge of the alleged crimes. On Friday, the three legs of the evidentiary stool built a solid moment for the prosecutors.

RELATED: Accountants testify Manafort falsified loan documents, hid foreign income on taxes

The jury read damning email messages and documents to support the bank fraud charges. A witness said she had discussed creating fake documents with Manafort and longtime deputy Rick Gates, then sent the faked documents to a bank on their behalf.

She also testified that she knew her tax firm had fudged a loan amount so a then-broke Manafort could save up to a half-million dollars in taxes.

It's the closest this trial has come to smoking guns so far.

2. Foreign bank account repetition

All three financial professionals who worked for Manafort -- the bookkeeper Heather Washkuhn and the accountants Philip Ayliff and Cindy Laporta -- sat through the same minute-long inquisition that appears to form the core of the prosecutors' foreign banking charges. Did you know Paul Manafort was affiliated with these companies? the prosecutor begins. He says one corporate name at a time, ending after 14 or 15. The witness says "no" to each.

Those are the offshore companies that prosecutors have already established paid for Manafort's personal excesses or "lent" him money.

The other thing prosecutors have established? That each of the financial professionals told Manafort explicitly and multiple times that he would break the law if he did not disclose his foreign accounts. He did not make those accounts known to them, all the witnesses said.

3. White-collar crime challenge

White-collar crime cases are notoriously hard to prosecute. This case has had hours of tax code explanation and tax returns, corporate financial accounting and the intricacies of loan, income and mortgage tax deductions.

Many a government attorney has lost a corporate financial case or had a mistrial because evidence became too dense, boring or confusing for the jury to follow.

Will Manafort's jurors face a similar result?

Throughout previous days and through Friday morning, some jurors grew fidgety or slouched in their chairs.

But when the prosecution neared the end of its questioning Friday, with the allegedly fake documents on the screen and a witness testifying to her own wrongdoing, the courtroom was rapt.

4. Witness believability

For three hours Friday, Laporta appeared to be a knowledgeable and careful accountant, describing with verve the way clients should report taxes and pausing to double-check evidence the prosecutors led her through. She came across as sincere -- even more so when she said that what she had done to help Manafort obtain bank loans was wrong.

"I very much regret it," Laporta said Friday. She testified that she had gone along with Manafort and Gates' allegedly fraudulent scheme because Manafort was a longtime customer of her firm, and she wanted to keep the firm out of immediate trouble.

In order for a jury to convict Manafort, Laporta's credibility must hold up. She'll be questioned by the defense team on Monday, and they've indicated to the court they'd like to raise the immunity deal she cut with prosecutors. Four more witnesses who have immunity -- meaning they, too, may have stepped out of line -- are positioned to testify. The defense may try to undercut their credibility as well.

Then, of course, there's Gates. He's already admitted guilt and to lying to federal authorities. Gates was a central player in passing the allegedly fake documents to banks, as shown Friday. He's certainly a key and coming witness -- one who could be impeached and pinned with crimes.

Prosecutors may have their own pocket ace on the Gates matter.

One of Manafort's defense lawyers sent prosecutors a statement after their client was indicted, creating a document that could destroy the defense's case. That document says Gates was "not involved" in some of Manafort's Cypriot banking. There isn't yet a resolution whether the jury will see that document.

New York Coronavirus Cases

County data is updated nightly.

Cases: 1962225

Reported Deaths: 51204
CountyCasesDeaths
Kings2593439882
Queens2589849503
Suffolk1904633298
Nassau1746733095
Bronx1723656353
New York1297814289
Westchester1240922234
Erie795801681
Richmond694401737
Monroe595391030
Orange45320782
Rockland45148935
Onondaga35415659
Dutchess27449430
Albany23323342
Oneida21214497
Niagara17712332
Broome17098348
Saratoga14122159
Ulster12755241
Schenectady12228190
Rensselaer10465135
Putnam1002391
Chautauqua8205132
Chemung7033133
Oswego685790
Ontario672091
Steuben6169141
St. Lawrence611394
Sullivan595868
Cayuga577890
Jefferson538163
Wayne511967
Cattaraugus501580
Genesee4996121
Herkimer4856107
Clinton444132
Madison423185
Tompkins400049
Fulton396186
Livingston392658
Montgomery3802114
Columbia379399
Cortland350260
Warren331455
Tioga330458
Wyoming319851
Allegany312983
Otsego310246
Greene306674
Chenango300773
Washington279555
Orleans269783
Lewis240833
Franklin236512
Delaware210336
Seneca184356
Schoharie149815
Essex148326
Yates109126
Schuyler97513
Hamilton2962
Unassigned16389
Out of NY0215
Rome
Clear
39° wxIcon
Hi: 66° Lo: 40°
Feels Like: 39°
Binghamton
Clear
47° wxIcon
Hi: 64° Lo: 33°
Feels Like: 47°
Rome
Clear
39° wxIcon
Hi: 68° Lo: 39°
Feels Like: 39°
Rome
Partly Cloudy
39° wxIcon
Hi: 63° Lo: 39°
Feels Like: 39°
WKTV Radar
WKTV Temperatures
WKTV Severe Weather
Saluting Those Who Are Proud 2 Serve
Enter the Rock Your Body Giveaway from Alivana Aesthetics
Looking for work or looking to hire? Check out the WKTV Job Fair!