Larry Nassar's motion to disqualify Judge Rosemarie Aquilina denied

A motion filed by attorneys for Larry Nassar seeking to disqualify Judge Rosemarie Aquilina from presiding o...

Posted: Aug 14, 2018 9:34 PM
Updated: Aug 14, 2018 9:34 PM

A motion filed by attorneys for Larry Nassar seeking to disqualify Judge Rosemarie Aquilina from presiding over any further proceedings in Nassar's case was denied Tuesday.

The ruling means Aquilina, who admonished the disgraced former USA Gymnastics doctor during his sentencing, can be involved in matters related to Nassar's request for resentencing.

Crime, law enforcement and corrections

Crimes against persons

Criminal offenses

Larry Nassar

Misc people

Rosemarie Aquilina

Sex and gender issues

Sex crimes

Sexual assault

Society

Sports figures

Criminal law

Law and legal system

Sentencing

Corrections system

Prisons and jails

Aquilina sentenced Nassar in January to 40 to 175 years in prison after he pleaded guilty to seven counts of sexual misconduct. Before the sentencing, more than 150 women and girls said in court that Nassar had sexually abused them under the guise of providing medical treatment.

Aquilina followed their testimony with an impassioned statement, during which she ripped into the doctor.

"And I want you to know, as much as it was my honor and privilege to hear the survivors, it is my honor and privilege to sentence you," Aquilina told Nassar. "Because, sir, you do not deserve to walk outside of a prison ever again."

Nassar's attorneys argued in their July request for Nassar's resentencing and Aquilina's disqualification that the judge had demonstrated bias used the sentencing "as an opportunity to advance her own agenda, including to advocate for policy initiatives within the state as well as the federal legislatures, to push for broader cultural change regarding gender equity and sexual discrimination issues, and, seemingly, as a type of group therapy for the victims."

In his ruling, Ingham County, Michigan Chief Circuit Court and Probate Judge Richard J. Garcia rejected the claim that Aquilina had demonstrated bias during Nassar's sentencing.

"Consideration of whether he should be resentenced can be fairly reviewed by the judge uniquely situated to provide justice in this case," Garcia wrote. "The judge who heard these survivors is the only one who should properly render any re-sentence."

Garcia also defended the two Aquilina statements that he said appeared to be the crux of Nassar's argument to disqualify the judge.

Nassar's attorneys had said that Aquilina should not have referred to the sentencing agreement as Nassar's "death warrant" nor said that she "would allow someone or many people to do to (Nassar) what he did to others" if the US Constitution allowed "cruel and unusual punishment."

The death warrant comment, Garcia wrote, only explained that Nassar would spend the rest of his life in jail.

The comment about punishment "simply attempted to impress upon the defendant his good fortune that he was protected by own Constitution," Garcia wrote. "They also communicated to the survivors that she understood the depth of society's visceral natural desire for vengeance...Such passionate elocution is not the basis of disqualification."

Garcia also wrote that Aquilina's subsequent statements about the case on social media and appearance at the ESPY Awards "do not constitute impermissible bias nor are they evidence of impartiality."

"Defendant apparently wishes to be resentenced before a judge who is ambivalent about the suffering of victims," Garcia wrote. "This standard should disqualify any judge with a pulse."

The office of Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette also has backed the judge and called Nassar "arguably the most destructive serial sexual predator in the history of the state, perhaps the country."

Nassar is expected to begin serving Aquilina's sentence after serving a 60-year sentence in a federal prison on child pornography charges.

Nassar's attorneys have not responded to a request for comment.

New York Coronavirus Cases

County data is updated nightly.

Cases: 1650303

Reported Deaths: 47719
CountyCasesDeaths
Queens2118128784
Kings2109509118
Suffolk1628183086
Nassau1486692918
Bronx1445195881
Westchester1078572101
New York1039223906
Erie654191603
Richmond572011579
Monroe52679991
Rockland38628889
Orange37059720
Onondaga32452630
Dutchess22387408
Albany20890332
Oneida19735478
Niagara15324312
Broome14870336
Saratoga11970145
Schenectady10842178
Ulster10069228
Rensselaer9039132
Putnam836986
Chautauqua7336123
Chemung6440130
Oswego600289
Ontario580188
St. Lawrence553285
Steuben5509137
Cayuga537988
Jefferson480663
Sullivan475559
Herkimer4561107
Wayne447364
Cattaraugus442076
Genesee4411118
Madison384885
Clinton361026
Livingston355056
Tompkins345742
Columbia340096
Fulton333784
Montgomery3190107
Cortland316760
Allegany290481
Warren284155
Wyoming282049
Tioga280656
Greene264871
Orleans245181
Chenango243969
Otsego235543
Washington234352
Franklin208712
Lewis206730
Seneca162053
Delaware151933
Essex134226
Schoharie121012
Yates101426
Schuyler86812
Hamilton2842
Unassigned221140
Out of NY0192
Syracuse
Mostly Cloudy
22° wxIcon
Hi: 37° Lo: 5°
Feels Like: 22°
Binghamton
Partly Cloudy
24° wxIcon
Hi: 38° Lo: 7°
Feels Like: 16°
Mostly Cloudy
° wxIcon
Hi: 39° Lo: 7°
Feels Like: °
Cloudy
° wxIcon
Hi: 32° Lo: -4°
Feels Like: °
WKTV Radar
WKTV Temperatures
WKTV Severe Weather
Submit your Mutt Madness Picture through March 10th
March into Beautiful Skin Giveaway
2021 Golfer's Paradise Card - 21 Courses for only $99.99
Saluting Those Who Are Proud 2 Serve