Trump's plan for Syria withdrawal changes again

Pentagon officials told President Donald Trump that his order to withdraw troops from Syria within 30 days was physically impossible without significant risk to US forces, multiple informed sources tell CNN, and the new 120-day timeline is not an example of anything but reality, logistics, and physics.

Posted: Jan 3, 2019 5:38 PM
Updated: Jan 3, 2019 5:40 PM

Pentagon officials told President Donald Trump that his order to withdraw troops from Syria within 30 days was physically impossible without significant risk to US forces, multiple informed sources tell CNN, and the new 120-day timeline is not an example of anything but reality, logistics, and physics.

Despite this fact, Trump administration officials are casting the new timeline as a slowdown and an example of the President being reasonable after hearing pushback from the Pentagon and allies such as Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-South Carolina.

"I said, 'You know, I never said that I'm going to rush out,'" the President told Fox News Channel in an interview that ran on Monday.

Administration officials told reporters that the President was now granting the military several months for the withdrawal while Graham told journalists Sunday, "I think we're slowing things down in a smart way ... I think we're in a pause situation where we are re-evaluating what's the best way to achieve the President's objective of having people pay more and do more."

In truth, the sources say, the 120-day timeline that's being reported as a slowdown is not a slowdown in any way, it's the minimal timeline the military needs to even execute the abrupt and sudden order in a safe and orderly manner.

The 120-day timeline is the military "trying to please the President and not get everyone killed," one Pentagon official told CNN. "They should probably take longer if you ask me."

The reality behind the schedule is just the latest example of administration officials reeling from a decision they believe to be a potentially devastating mistake, one that provoked a more negative response than the President had anticipated, including the resignations of his widely respected secretary of defense, retired Marine Gen. James Mattis, and the special presidential envoy for the campaign to defeat ISIS, Brett McGurk.

These sources, who would only speak on background so as to avoid the ire of the President and/or avoid further administration chaos, note that Trump's original decision was impulsive. On a phone call with Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the President suddenly said the US would get out of Syria as soon as possible and then refused to reconsider when pressed to do so by advisers.

Pentagon officials came back and told him it was impossible to withdraw in fewer than 120 days, the sources say. The President then accepted 120 days but took to Twitter to say the troops were "slowly" being sent back home.

"The minimum period required to execute this reckless decision is now being portrayed as 'well thought out and deliberate' when it's neither of those things," an informed source tells CNN. "It's a total capitulation to Erdogan and an abandonment of the very fighters in Syria who are fighting ISIS and protecting US forces. The military simply cannot get out safely in less than 120 days."

Pentagon officials describe the withdrawal timeline as being 50% logistics and 50% security. The physical removal of service members from start to finish would only take about a month, but more time is needed to move equipment out of the theater and coordinate airlifts.

One source referred to the heavy amount of ordnance and ammunition the US has in Syria that cannot just be left behind, nor can it be moved quickly.

Beyond the facts behind the order, military and intelligence officials continue to try to impress upon the President their view that the decision to withdraw will have dire consequences including causing a resurgence of ISIS.

Some officials have asked about the historical precedent for a declaration of victory and if a withdrawal like this has ever worked.

One outstanding item, of many: the Global Coalition to Defeat ISIS next meets in the coming weeks at the State Department, hosted by Secretary of State Mike Pompeo. He will no doubt face some tough questions from representatives of the 73 other member countries and five institutions such as the European Union and NATO, including explaining how the US made such a dramatic decision without any serious input from allies and against the assessment of intelligence agencies.

It's not just partners who are worried. Officials at the Department of Homeland Security, a senior administration official tells CNN, are extremely concerned that the decision could give ISIS free reign to reconstitute and are alarmed about the impact it will have in the medium term on homeland security.

Administration officials are likewise skeptical that Erdogan and the Turkish military have the will or the ability to defeat whatever remains of ISIS. They add that Erdogan's real objective is to fight the very Kurds who have been fighting ISIS alongside American forces.

"Trump says the United States has been suckered for too long, but in this case Trump was suckered by Erdogan," the source, familiar with the deliberations told CNN. "He signed up to a program against the interests of the United States that nobody in his own military believes advisable or implementable."

"There's some very stupid stuff going on and it's a lie to say there is a plan of any kind," the source tells CNN. "There is no plan."

New York Coronavirus Cases

County data is updated nightly.

Cases: 2158388

Reported Deaths: 53670
CountyCasesDeaths
Kings28928110524
Queens28365510025
Suffolk2050963414
Nassau1880503186
Bronx1874406599
New York1438304539
Westchester1318572296
Erie909191816
Richmond776231856
Monroe701341117
Orange49181847
Rockland47596758
Onondaga39672680
Dutchess29976447
Albany25156358
Oneida22886518
Niagara20315375
Broome18850367
Saratoga15842168
Ulster14186258
Schenectady13432206
Rensselaer11494145
Putnam1078393
Chautauqua9024146
Chemung7856137
Oswego773493
Ontario753493
Steuben7027147
Sullivan681276
St. Lawrence676797
Cayuga643592
Jefferson628668
Wayne586873
Cattaraugus580893
Genesee5461124
Herkimer5273110
Clinton489133
Madison461989
Livingston456960
Fulton447993
Tompkins446953
Montgomery4309128
Columbia4152104
Cortland398064
Tioga388363
Warren378162
Wyoming363153
Allegany358287
Chenango357277
Otsego351347
Greene347579
Washington322355
Orleans314683
Lewis284836
Franklin257912
Delaware244339
Seneca204357
Schoharie174319
Essex163626
Yates118326
Schuyler109014
Hamilton3182
Unassigned9214
Out of NY0254
Utica
Clear
78° wxIcon
Hi: 78° Lo: 51°
Feels Like: 79°
Oneonta
Partly Cloudy
72° wxIcon
Hi: 74° Lo: 49°
Feels Like: 72°
Herkimer
Clear
80° wxIcon
Hi: 80° Lo: 52°
Feels Like: 80°
Old Forge
Partly Cloudy
78° wxIcon
Hi: 75° Lo: 50°
Feels Like: 79°
WKTV Radar
WKTV Temperatures
WKTV Severe Weather

18 Facets of Summer Photo Contest brought to you by Herkimer Diamond Mines
Senior Send-Off brought to you by Herkimer College
Looking for work or looking to hire? Check out the WKTV Job Fair!
Saluting Those Who Are Proud 2 Serve