Who gets blamed for a government shutdown?

Now that the partial shutdown of the federal government has become the ...

Posted: Jan 11, 2019 2:06 PM
Updated: Jan 11, 2019 2:06 PM

Now that the partial shutdown of the federal government has become the longest in American history, and with no end in sight as President Donald Trump and House Democrats dig in over his proposal for a border wall, it's worth revisiting who is likely to pay a political price.

Who would own the shutdown has been a point of contention between the two parties. In early December during a televised Oval Office meeting about the shutdown, Trump said, "I'll tell you what, I am proud to shut down the government for border security, Chuck. So, I will take the mantle. I will be the one to shut it down. I'm not going to blame you for it."

Bill Clinton

Budget deficits

Business, economy and trade

Donald Trump

Economy and economic indicators

Federal budget

Federal budget deficit

Government and public administration

Government bodies and offices

Government budgets

Government organizations - US

Political Figures - US

Political organizations

Political platforms and issues

Politics

Public debt

Public finance

US Congress

US Democratic Party

US federal government

US federal government shutdowns

US political parties

US Republican Party

White House

US House of Representatives

Schumer has seized on that declaration by Trump even as the President has sought more recently to shift blame to Democrats.

"The President made clear he wants a shutdown," said Schumer after the meeting. And a shutdown we've got.

Starting with the mid-1990s clashes between President Bill Clinton and Newt Gingrich's Republican majority in Congress, there have been seven government shutdowns or close calls that were the subject of polling. While each situation was unique, Republicans have been blamed for most of them, although Democrats took the blame for the most recent, a short affair back in January, even though Republicans controlled the House, Senate and White House at the time. The President hasn't been blamed in any of the previous shutdowns.

The shutdowns in late 1995 and 1995-96 were clearly blamed on the Republicans, who controlled the House and Senate at the time even though a Democrat, Clinton, was in the White House. There was a partial shutdown in November 1995 and a full shutdown from December of 1995 into January 1996. Seven polls were conducted prior to, during and after those shutdowns asking who was to blame -- Clinton or the Republicans in Congress -- for their lack of compromise. A plurality of respondents said Republicans were more to blame than Clinton in every single poll. Between 43% and 51% blamed Republicans and between 25% and 34% blamed Clinton, depending on the poll.

In 1998, the government almost shut down when Clinton and the Republicans struggled to find compromise on a budget deal. Only one poll was taken on the possible shutdown, by Gallup/CNN/USA Today, and 56% of Americans said they would blame the Republican leaders in Congress if the government had to shut down.

Fast-forward to the next Democratic President, Barack Obama, who was working with a Republican-controlled House and a Democratic-led Senate. After days of budget battles in Congress, a shutdown was avoided at the last minute in 2011. Thirty-seven percent said in an NBC/WSJ poll that they would blame the Republicans in Congress over Democrats in Congress (20%) or Obama (20%).

A shutdown in 2013 and near-shutdown in 2015 tell similar stories. In the six polls that asked who would be blamed for the 16-day shutdown in 2013, more people -- between 38% and 53% -- attributed the blame to the Republicans in Congress. In 2015, when Republicans controlled both the House and Senate, two polls found the blame would go to Republicans and one poll showed a torn public, with some blaming Republicans and some blaming Obama and the Democrats.

While these shutdowns (or close calls) all carry the blame for Republicans, they also share similar circumstances. In 1995, 1996, 1998, 2011, 2013 and 2015, there was a Democratic president in the White House and at least one chamber of Congress controlled by the Republican Party (in four cases, both chambers were controlled by Republicans). So while this could be about blaming Republicans, the shutdown in 2018 shows it may be about blaming the opposite party of the President.

In early 2018, Democrats, despite holding neither chamber of Congress nor the White House, caused a brief shutdown over the plight of the children of undocumented immigrants Trump had stripped of protected status. Seven polls asked who should be or was going to be blamed for the shutdown. Three polls were torn between blaming Republicans and Democrats, two found a plurality who attributed responsibility to the Republicans, one poll went for the Democrats and one was torn between Democrats and Trump.

So Americans seemed to blame everyone that time around. Fewer blamed Trump (between 16% and 31%) than Democrats (between 29% and 34%), but both parties were, in the end, held responsible for the gridlock that caused a shutdown. But that's a change from the past four almost or actual shutdowns.

And now, in early 2019? The showdown is over Trump's demand for funding for his wall at the border with Mexico, and Democrats are balking at additional border security money because they say more than $1 billion allocated in January was not entirely spent. Trump holds the presidency, but Democrats newly hold the majority in the House. This blame could be placed on the Democrats, as the opposing party to the President (and would fit with the 1998-2015 trend) or it could be seen as everyone's fault (fitting with the shutdown in early 2018).

New York Coronavirus Cases

County data is updated nightly.

Cases: 2111556

Reported Deaths: 53604
CountyCasesDeaths
Kings28079410461
Queens2774949966
Suffolk2011683400
Nassau1837533176
Bronx1836956583
New York1384044508
Westchester1297282291
Erie896041809
Richmond750591840
Monroe690541112
Orange48337843
Rockland46965963
Onondaga38970678
Dutchess29483445
Albany24712357
Oneida22637516
Niagara20045374
Broome18633366
Saratoga15389168
Ulster13916257
Schenectady13207205
Rensselaer11235143
Putnam1062292
Chautauqua8958145
Chemung7774136
Oswego762792
Ontario740893
Steuben6957145
Sullivan667976
St. Lawrence664697
Cayuga633892
Jefferson615568
Wayne578570
Cattaraugus572391
Genesee5437124
Herkimer5193109
Clinton483833
Madison456589
Livingston452460
Fulton442392
Tompkins435052
Montgomery4254127
Columbia4068104
Cortland392963
Tioga383463
Warren366157
Wyoming358453
Allegany355987
Chenango350476
Otsego346347
Greene340579
Washington316255
Orleans312183
Lewis281136
Franklin256312
Delaware238538
Seneca201156
Schoharie169317
Essex159326
Yates117926
Schuyler108014
Hamilton3132
Unassigned10016
Out of NY0250
Utica
Partly Cloudy
80° wxIcon
Hi: 81° Lo: 57°
Feels Like: 81°
Oneonta
Mostly Cloudy
76° wxIcon
Hi: 79° Lo: 57°
Feels Like: 76°
Herkimer
Partly Cloudy
80° wxIcon
Hi: 84° Lo: 58°
Feels Like: 81°
Old Forge
Partly Cloudy
80° wxIcon
Hi: 76° Lo: 57°
Feels Like: 81°
WKTV Radar
WKTV Temperatures
WKTV Severe Weather
Senior Send-Off brought to you by Herkimer College
18 Facets of Summer Photo Contest brought to you by Herkimer Diamond Mines
Looking for work or looking to hire? Check out the WKTV Job Fair!
Alivana Ready for Summer Giveaway
Saluting Those Who Are Proud 2 Serve