SEVERE WX : Winter Weather Advisory - Wind Chill Advisory View Alerts
STREAMING NOW: Watch Now

Bernie Sanders is no Donald Trump

Article Image

CNN's SE Cupp, Van Jones and John Avlon discuss President Trump's frequent misleading claims.

Posted: Apr 3, 2019 9:10 PM
Updated: Apr 3, 2019 9:10 PM

As is fashionable during election season, candidates will be compared to others, both current and past, living and dead. It's a fun game, and can have some real usefulness as we try to learn from the failures and successes of previous eras and administrations.

But other times, the desire to find quick commonality between two disparate figures can be too cute by half. And at worst, it's actually counterproductive and even offensive.

"Bernie Sanders has emerged as the Donald Trump of the left," reads the Washington Post headline above opinion writer Dana Milbank's column.

This piqued my interest, as many WaPo headlines and Milbank posts do.

But what followed wasn't just disappointing, it was ludicrous.

His first attempt at persuading you of this notion is in his first full paragraph: "Fundraising and polls show that many Democrats think the best answer to an angry old white guy with crazy hair, New York accent and flair for demagoguery is, well, another angry old white guy with crazy hair, New York accent and flair for demagoguery."

Don't spend too much time parsing this. I'm sure if Bernie supporters were asked, few would say his hair, accent and rhetorical panache were the reason they liked him. But let's give this comparison the benefit of the doubt for now, and assume it goes somewhere convincing.

"Sanders himself remains untouchable, in a Trumpian way," Milbank offers. One piece of evidence? "Claims of mistreatment by male staffers from women who worked on his 2016 campaign" were met with a "yawn."

Let's DO parse this one.

Suffice it to say, it's an ill-advised exercise to equate complaints of harassment by women against men on a single campaign to credible accusations made by more than a dozen women of actual sexual assault against the actual candidate. These things are very different -- and women don't want all behaviors conflated into one blob-like superforce of patriarchy.

But also, neither was met with a "yawn." Trump's "Access Hollywood" tape was a huge story, it just didn't resonate with enough voters to ultimately take him down. Allegations against Sanders' campaign have been met with, I believe, the appropriate level of "awakeness."

From here, Milbank makes an important, if obvious, stipulation: "Sanders isn't Trump in the race-baiting, lender-cheating, fact-avoiding, porn-actress-paying, Putin-loving sense."

Hold on. So really, Sanders and Trump aren't alike in any meaningful way, like how they view humanity, their ethical and moral compasses, their relationship with the truth -- in other words, the most important ways.

"But their styles are similar," Milbank goes on. I'm listening...

"(S)houting and unsmiling, anti-establishment and anti-media, absolutely convinced of their own correctness, attacking boogeymen (the "1%" and CEOs in Sanders's case, instead of immigrants and minorities), offering impractical promises with vague details, lacking nuance and nostalgic for the past."

Try this experiment: Take out the parenthetical and pretend you don't know who this is describing. It could literally be any one of a dozen candidates, because what Milbank is accusing Sanders of being is merely a politician.

Let's forget about his hair, his accent and his "style" and have a serious conversation. Bernie Sanders is nothing like Donald Trump. That's because no one is like Donald Trump. He is, in ways that are both impressive and disturbing, inimitable, unprecedented, unique.

Sanders is, if anything, mundane. Because he is in many ways a typical politician. That means, among other things, he is often hypocritical, attacking the 1% while stalling on releasing his own tax returns, as Milbank points out. It means he often talks in platitudes and hypotheticals, providing little detail or proof of concept (have you met Beto O'Rourke?). It means he rails against the "establishment" (see Hillary Clinton, Elizabeth Warren, every Tea Party Republican and every progressive Democrat).

Trump is unique because his goal -- his only goal -- is to sow distrust and discord, not for any policy or political gains, but for his own self-gain and self-preservation. He himself motivates everything he does, and everything outside of him is expendable, from the party to our institutions to civility and our safety.

Whatever you think of Bernie Sanders' policies -- and I can't find many I'd support -- let's dispose of the notion that he, or any other candidate, is like Trump.

New York Coronavirus Cases

County data is updated nightly.

Cases: 1309403

Reported Deaths: 41974
CountyCasesDeaths
Queens1634647942
Kings1605728149
Suffolk1327482661
Nassau1187352597
Bronx1092905316
Westchester875701832
New York781983480
Erie536051407
Richmond464421394
Monroe45400804
Rockland32660821
Orange29753661
Onondaga28476541
Dutchess17424330
Oneida17346369
Albany17045266
Niagara12602251
Broome11657269
Saratoga968986
Schenectady9021135
Ulster8017199
Rensselaer7262109
Putnam674875
Chautauqua584470
Chemung5739109
Oswego505974
Ontario485583
Steuben4719131
Cayuga460874
Sullivan395449
St. Lawrence385563
Herkimer383967
Wayne381156
Genesee3803101
Cattaraugus352862
Jefferson338827
Madison324376
Livingston281542
Tompkins277925
Cortland271054
Columbia264573
Allegany241375
Montgomery234277
Clinton231718
Tioga229454
Wyoming228444
Fulton224155
Warren220142
Greene214063
Orleans200371
Chenango185044
Otsego180324
Washington161227
Lewis158224
Seneca127647
Franklin12699
Delaware106727
Essex101721
Schoharie9436
Yates86320
Schuyler74510
Hamilton1611
Unassigned62117
Out of NY0168
Rome
Cloudy
13° wxIcon
Hi: 15° Lo: 11°
Feels Like: 2°
Binghamton
Cloudy
15° wxIcon
Hi: 17° Lo: 14°
Feels Like: -1°
Rome
Cloudy
13° wxIcon
Hi: 16° Lo: 14°
Feels Like: 2°
Rome
Cloudy
13° wxIcon
Hi: 8° Lo: 3°
Feels Like: 2°
WKTV Radar
WKTV Temperatures
WKTV Severe Weather
2021 Golfer's Paradise Card - 21 Courses for only $99.99
Saluting Those Who Are Proud 2 Serve