SEVERE WX : Winter Weather Advisory View Alerts

Image consultants: Here's the debate's biggest loser

Article Image

Former Housing and Urban Development Secretary Julián Castro challenged former Rep. Beto O'Rourke on how to process immigrants seeking asylum or entry at the US border.

Posted: Jun 27, 2019 7:50 AM
Updated: Jun 27, 2019 7:50 AM

Ask the average American what was "sticky" from the first Democratic presidential debate, and there's a good chance it had nothing to do with domestic or foreign policy. Cory Booker's meme-worthy look of astonishment as Beto O'Rourke began speaking Spanish went viral, and later MSNBC got its microphone wires crossed, which may have been the only truly unscripted moment of the evening.

As for the actual debate, 10 Democratic candidates for president lined the stage Wednesday night, but four stood out above the rest. Elizabeth Warren won. O'Rourke lost. Bill de Blasio and Julian Castro likely surprised people in a good way. Booker had a moment when he personalized his answer on gun control, but mainly, he spoke the most but said the least. The rest of the candidates often seemed like background noise.

We analyzed both the verbal and nonverbal communication skills of each candidate; it was clear that everyone had a moment to shine and a moment that left them wishing for a do-over.

Warren appeared to use her depth of knowledge to answer the questions instead of shamelessly bridging to a recitation of her past accomplishments.

Warren's high point: the authenticity and conviction with which she claimed how hard she would fight for the average American.

Her low point: smiling while listening to a question about the Parkland, Florida, school shooting.

De Blasio's height wasn't the only reason for his commanding presence on stage. The New York mayor spoke with a confidence and calm that made him seem up to the job.

De Blasio's high point: the clarity with which he called for adherence to the War Powers Act, saying that clearly we hadn't learned the lessons from Vietnam.

His low point: answering the first two questions looking straight into the camera. It seemed too sales-y.

Castro demonstrated an appealing range of emotion. Unlike many of his fellow candidates who seemed riled and angry, Castro demonstrated a cool confidence and a fiery passion over the issues.

Castro's high point: His use of Spanish was the only good one and not just because it was culturally appropriate. Castro spoke in the language of his family's heritage for a specific purpose that he explained: to show how far we've come as a country that he could do so. Booker's and O'Rourke's use of Spanish was borderline cringeworthy. Castro also teed up a good punchline seconds later when he said it was time to say "adios" to Donald Trump.

His low point: While listening to a question, Castro had a somewhat imperious look about him, with his head angled slightly up; he appeared to be judgmentally looking down his nose at the moderator.

O'Rourke's performance had more ups and downs than his Adam's apple as he appeared to listen nervously to the questions. When he abruptly and gratuitously broke into Spanish during his very first answer (can you say overeager?), Booker must not have been the only one who was astonished. Millions of viewers must have checked to see whether they had accidentally hit the SAP button on their remotes. Speaking Spanish to win over voters is nothing new. Jackie Kennedy did it several times in 1960, but as Lloyd Bentsen might have said, "Congressman. ... You're no Jackie Kennedy."

O'Rourke's high point: While answering a question about America's obligation to step in and combat episodes of genocide, the former congressman finally looked like he woke from his nationally televised slumber.

His low point: When Castro was telling O'Rourke he was wrong for not endorsing a repeal of Section 1325 of the Immigration and Nationality Act, O'Rourke nodded his head in a way that made it look like he was agreeing with the criticism. It was clear that O'Rourke came armed with stories about average people, but the stories frequently fell flat and felt unconnected to the rest of what he was saying.

But perhaps "The Biggest Loser" of the evening was the former host of "The Apprentice," who was barely mentioned by name. In fact, if Washington Gov. Jay Inslee hadn't named Trump as the biggest threat to America's national security, you could almost, for a few fleeting moments, have forgotten who sits in the Oval Office. Imagine that.

New York Coronavirus Cases

County data is updated nightly.

Cases: 2699233

Reported Deaths: 57322
CountyCasesDeaths
Kings34720810951
Queens32440110394
Suffolk2527993673
Nassau2239883326
Bronx2123706802
New York1755004657
Westchester1473702354
Erie1222932028
Monroe960181244
Richmond919661967
Orange61473944
Onondaga58601808
Rockland55139782
Dutchess37627507
Albany33929409
Oneida32627634
Niagara28121414
Broome27865432
Saratoga24009222
Schenectady19020243
Ulster18785288
Rensselaer17067192
Chautauqua14614189
Oswego13890132
Putnam13013101
Chemung12630174
St. Lawrence12554143
Steuben12197187
Ontario11437118
Jefferson11088105
Wayne9986101
Cattaraugus9777154
Cayuga9585112
Sullivan939390
Genesee8444143
Herkimer8139141
Clinton790446
Fulton7678109
Tompkins728161
Madison7219108
Warren707094
Livingston703775
Montgomery7027159
Washington645676
Tioga623673
Cortland602088
Allegany5867119
Columbia5600113
Chenango545295
Orleans535995
Otsego525561
Franklin525325
Wyoming516664
Greene486188
Delaware428251
Lewis412539
Seneca314567
Essex292737
Schoharie261524
Yates195333
Schuyler187620
Hamilton5103
Unassigned1362
Out of NY0336
Utica
Cloudy
32° wxIcon
Hi: 37° Lo: 29°
Feels Like: 20°
Oneonta
Cloudy
27° wxIcon
Hi: 38° Lo: 27°
Feels Like: 14°
Herkimer
Cloudy
32° wxIcon
Hi: 39° Lo: 31°
Feels Like: 20°
Old Forge
Cloudy
32° wxIcon
Hi: 35° Lo: 23°
Feels Like: 20°
WKTV Radar
WKTV Temperatures
WKTV Severe Weather
Game Day Deals - New Deals Each Week
Stuff the Bus Locations
Saluting Those Who Are Proud 2 Serve