Supreme Court sides with Planned Parenthood in funding fight

The Supreme Court Monday rebuffed efforts by states to block fundin...

Posted: Dec 10, 2018 11:46 AM
Updated: Dec 10, 2018 1:00 PM

The Supreme Court Monday rebuffed efforts by states to block funding to Planned Parenthood.

It left in place two lower court opinions that said that states violate federal law when they terminate Medicaid contracts with Planned Parenthood affiliates who offer preventive care for low income women.

It would have taken four justices to agree to hear the issue, and only three conservative justices -- Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch -- voted to hear the case.

Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Brett Kavanaugh appeared to side with the court's liberals in not taking up the case -- showing an effort to avoid high-profile abortion-related issues for now.

Roberts and Kavanaugh 'likely have serious objections,' said Steve Vladeck, CNN Supreme Court analyst and professor at the University of Texas School of Law. 'But such votes seem to be a signal that they would rather avoid contentious, high-profile disputes for now, at least where possible.'

At issue is not whether states can provide federal funding for abortion. Instead, the case concerned whether they can block Medicaid funds from offices that provide such women with annual health screens, contraceptive coverage and cancer screening.

Thomas wrote a dissent for the three conservatives, saying the court isn't doing its job.

'What explains the Court's refusal to do its job here?' Thomas wrote.

'I suspect it has something to do with the fact that some respondents in these cases are named Planned Parenthood,' he wrote.

'But these cases are not about abortion rights,' he said. 'They are about private rights of action under the Medicaid Act. Resolving the question presented here would not even affect Planned Parenthood's ability to challenge the states' decisions; it concerns only the rights of individual Medicaid patients to bring their own suits.'

'Broad authority'

Kansas -- one of the states that had asked the Supreme Court to step in -- wanted the justices to review a lower court opinion that held that while states have 'broad authority' to ensure that Medicaid health care providers are qualified to provide medical services, 'the power has limits.'

'States may not terminate providers from their Medicaid program for any reason they see fit, especially when that reason is unrelated to the provider's competence and the quality of the health care it provides' a panel of judges on the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals held last February.

Kansas and Louisiana moved to terminate Medicaid contracts with the affiliates after a group opposing abortion published edited videos in 2014 they said depicted officials Planned Parenthood Federation of America discussing fetal tissue and appearing to talk about the price of such tissue.

Planned Parenthood later filed a lawsuit against the group, Center for Medical Progress, alleging that defendants lied their way into the recorded meetings and set up a fake company and personal identities to pull off the videos.

In court briefs, lawyers for Kansas argued that the lower court opinion gives 'millions of Medicaid beneficiaries the ability to go directly to federal court to challenge a state's determination that their provider is not 'qualified' -- bypassing layers of state administrative review.'

Planned Parenthood argued that Kansas terminated the Medicaid provider agreements with two affiliates 'without cause.'

New York Coronavirus Cases

County data is updated nightly.

Cases: 655265

Reported Deaths: 34662
CountyCasesDeaths
Queens910567356
Kings897517509
Bronx644945024
Suffolk616812056
Nassau611622260
Westchester512201517
New York458713229
Erie26042826
Richmond233761134
Rockland21845692
Orange17075517
Monroe16060313
Onondaga10995222
Dutchess7354191
Albany5968148
Broome5448149
Oneida5084154
Niagara4019111
Ulster343498
Chemung310949
Putnam288464
Schenectady255560
Saratoga237021
Sullivan221048
Steuben182487
Rensselaer179554
Oswego16849
Chautauqua160916
Ontario135437
Wayne117516
Cattaraugus116426
Tioga115351
Tompkins11393
Cortland10824
Genesee107610
Allegany105856
Columbia103558
Madison96318
Cayuga9178
St. Lawrence87416
Livingston73811
Herkimer73112
Greene71018
Chenango64910
Otsego6498
Orleans63457
Warren59535
Jefferson5864
Wyoming5648
Fulton51828
Montgomery51017
Clinton4805
Washington45714
Lewis3809
Delaware3759
Schuyler3203
Seneca3205
Essex28914
Franklin2717
Yates2697
Schoharie2082
Hamilton471
Out of NY0126
Unassigned035
Utica
Overcast
34° wxIcon
Hi: 33° Lo: 30°
Feels Like: 25°
Oneonta
Overcast
32° wxIcon
Hi: 31° Lo: 28°
Feels Like: 24°
Herkimer
Overcast
34° wxIcon
Hi: 33° Lo: 31°
Feels Like: 25°
Thendara
Overcast
34° wxIcon
Hi: 28° Lo: 24°
Feels Like: 25°
WKTV Radar
WKTV Temperatures
WKTV Severe Weather
2021 Golfer's Paradise Card - 21 Courses for only $99.99
PINZ Vouchers 50% off through December 10
Stuff the Bus Locations
Saluting Those Who Are Proud 2 Serve