Supreme Court upholds block on Trump's asylum ban

CNN's Jeffrey Toobin reacts to the Supreme Court's ruling that upholds a federal judge's order blocking the Trump administration's new asylum restrictions.

Posted: Dec 21, 2018 5:31 PM
Updated: Dec 21, 2018 5:45 PM


The Supreme Court on Friday upheld a federal judge's order blocking the Trump administration's new asylum restrictions.

Chief Justice John Roberts sided with the four liberal justices in the 5-4 ruling.

The administration's policy, signed on November 9, would temporarily bar migrants who illegally cross into the US through the southern border from seeking asylum outside of official ports of entry. A federal judge in California quickly blocked the order, and the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals agreed.

'It's a major blow to the Trump administration and sends a strong signal that there are at least five justices who agree with the district court that the asylum ban exceeds the President's statutory authority,' said Steve Vladeck, CNN Supreme Court analyst and professor at the University of Texas School of Law.

Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh said they would have granted the administration's request to lift the hold on the ban. This is the first high-profile vote in which Kavanaugh broke from Roberts. Earlier this year, he and Roberts joined with liberals to rebuff efforts by states seeking to eliminate funding for Planned Parenthood.

The court declined to say when or how Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who had surgery in New York Friday, cast her vote. Other justices are also not in Washington and they were not scheduled to meet as a group this week. In these situations, justices often vote by phone or email.

Roberts-Trump fight

The ruling emphasizes the power of Roberts, a conservative who has sparred at times with Trump, said CNN chief legal analyst Jeffrey Toobin.

'It is a more conservative court now than it was before Anthony Kennedy was replaced by Brett Kavanaugh, but Chief Justice Roberts is going to keep things moving at the customary pace of the Supreme Court, not as fast as the Trump administration wants to go,' Toobin told CNN's Pamela Brown.

'On this one question in a preliminary way, he has put the brakes on a Trump administration initiative and that's an embarrassment and it's a defeat for the President,' he added.

The court can still hear arguments on the merits of the asylum restrictions at a later date.

The asylum ban was at the center of an unusual fight between Roberts and President Donald Trump last month.

A district court ruled the ban 'irreconcilably conflicts' with immigration law. A panel of judges on the 9th Circuit upheld the injunction in an opinion penned by Judge Jay Bybee, a George W. Bush nominee. That led Trump to criticize the San Francisco-based appeals court, which has blocked other administration policies such as the travel ban.

That led Roberts, who has made a public push to emphasize the independence of the judiciary from the political branches, to issue a rare statement.

'The 9th Circuit, we're going to have to look at that,' Trump said, before adding that 'every case' that goes through that circuit results in 'an automatic loss' for his administration. 'The 9th Circuit is very unfair.'

That led Roberts, who has made a public push to emphasize the independence of the judiciary from the political branches, to issue a rare statement.

'We do not have Obama judges or Trump judges, Bush judges or Clinton judges,' Roberts said. 'What we have is an extraordinary group of dedicated judges doing their level best to do equal right to those appearing before them. That independent judiciary is something we should all be thankful for.'

Trump fired back.

'Sorry Chief Justice John Roberts, but you do indeed have 'Obama judges,' and they have a much different point of view than the people who are charged with the safety of our country. It would be great if the 9th Circuit was indeed an 'independent judiciary,' but if it is why......' Trump tweeted.

Several minutes later, he continued, '.....are so many opposing view (on Border and Safety) cases filed there, and why are a vast number of those cases overturned. Please study the numbers, they are shocking. We need protection and security - these rulings are making our country unsafe! Very dangerous and unwise!'

Aggressive administration strategy

Solicitor General Noel Francisco asked the Supreme Court to greenlight the regulations pending appeal because he said they are 'designed to channel asylum seekers to ports of entry, where their claims can be processed in an orderly manner; deter unlawful dangerous border crossings; and reduce the backlog of a meritless asylum claims.'

He said that contrary to the holding of the lower court, immigration law allows the attorney general and the secretary of homeland security to exercise their discretion to deny asylum to a migrant who has entered the nation illegally.

Francisco said that even if the justices decided not to lift the injunction they should scale back a nationwide injunction imposed by the lower court.

He also argued that the challengers did not have the legal right to bring the case because they are advocacy groups and not individual aliens.

But the Justice Department's strategy of aggressively filing appeals to the Supreme Court to overturn rulings unfavorable to the President may not be in keeping with the court's modus operandi, Toobin said.

'The Supreme Court doesn't like to be rushed, and Chief Justice Roberts in particular doesn't like to be rushed,' said Toobin. 'The Supreme Court operates at a very different pace than the rest of us -- they like to have full hearings on the merits, they don't care if it takes a couple extra months.'

ACLU attorney Lee Gelernt said the ruling 'will save lives and keep vulnerable families and children from persecution.'

'We are pleased the court refused to allow the administration to short-circuit the usual appellate process,' Gelernt said.

The Justice Department did not immediately return a request for comment.

New York Coronavirus Cases

County data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 419642

Reported Deaths: 32760
CountyConfirmedDeaths
New York City22725823567
Suffolk436811998
Nassau435802194
Westchester361361447
Rockland13925674
Orange11129491
Erie8791671
Monroe4901285
Dutchess4589153
Onondaga3556200
Albany2573128
Oneida2129115
Ulster204991
Niagara149198
Sullivan148848
Putnam144663
Broome111569
Schenectady105537
Rensselaer75930
Saratoga75217
Columbia53537
Madison41217
Ontario35734
Warren30733
Orleans29754
Steuben29742
Fulton29324
Greene29118
Genesee2775
Herkimer2704
St. Lawrence2634
Washington25614
Oswego2513
Chautauqua2499
Wayne2493
Tompkins2330
Chenango2156
Tioga19325
Livingston1748
Montgomery1704
Chemung1683
Cattaraugus1646
Cayuga1512
Jefferson1400
Clinton1274
Otsego1165
Wyoming1165
Delaware1044
Cortland950
Seneca873
Allegany791
Schoharie690
Yates567
Essex550
Franklin540
Lewis390
Schuyler220
Hamilton80
Unassigned00
Utica
Broken Clouds
84° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 62°
Feels Like: 86°
Oneonta
Broken Clouds
79° wxIcon
Hi: 80° Lo: 61°
Feels Like: 80°
Herkimer
Broken Clouds
84° wxIcon
Hi: 84° Lo: 63°
Feels Like: 86°
Thendara
Broken Clouds
84° wxIcon
Hi: 79° Lo: 57°
Feels Like: 86°
WKTV Radar
WKTV Temperatures
WKTV Severe Weather
Click here to learn more about A Healthier Mohawk Valley
Ask EPLC Sweepstakes
Saluting Those Who Are Proud 2 Serve
Senior Send-Off brought to you by Herkimer College
WKTV Golf Card - Under 150 left