Vaccine experts want the FDA to commit to 30,000 people in Covid-19 vaccine trials

Vaccine experts are worried that President Trump will exert political pressure to put a Covid-19 vaccine on the market before it's ready, and they want assur...

Posted: Jun 12, 2020 4:21 PM
Updated: Jun 12, 2020 4:28 PM

Vaccine experts are worried that President Trump will exert political pressure to put a Covid-19 vaccine on the market before it's ready, and they want assurances from the US Food and Drug Administration that it won't authorize a vaccine unless it has first been studied on at least 30,000 people in clinical studies.

The director of the National Institutes of Health has already said there needs to be 30,000 participants in the Phase 3 clinical trials.

"Each vaccine needs to be tested on about 30,000 volunteers," Dr. Francis Collins told CNN. "We don't believe that we have enough power in the analysis, to be able to document the vaccine works unless you get to roughly that number."

Art Caplan, a bioethicist who has been a consultant to the federal government and the World Health Organization on vaccine development, said he'd like to see the FDA make a similar statement to encourage trust in the vaccine.

A CNN poll in May found one-third of American said they would not try to get vaccinated against the coronavirus, even if the vaccine was low-cost and widely available

"Collins understands that this is necessary to convince a somewhat skeptical public," said Caplan, a professor at NYU Langone Health.

Michael Felberbaum, a spokesman for the FDA said the agency is not allowed to say how many study subjects will be involved, but that the FDA "will only approve a vaccine to prevent COVID-19 following a thorough review of the data" and "only after the agency makes a determination that there is evidence of the vaccine's effectiveness and that its benefits outweigh its risks."

"Typically, phase 3 trials are sized to allow accumulation of the number of cases required to test the study endpoint within a defined period of time. Thus, trial size depends on attack rates, enrollment rates, and the amount of time allotted for performing the trial," he added.

At a BIO Digital event on Tuesday, Dr. Peter Marks, director of the Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research at the FDA said his agency as well as regulators in other countries "understand that if you're going to be thinking about treating hundreds of millions of people with a vaccine, you're going to want to have safety data sets to start that are reasonably sized."

Concerns about an 'October surprise' from Trump

Last month, Trump announced "Operation Warp Speed," noting that it's moving with "record, record, record speed."

The University of Oxford has started a Phase 3 trial on its vaccine candidate. Together with its partner, AstraZeneca, they expect to vaccinate 42,000 people.

Moderna plans to start its Phase 3 trial of 30,000 participants in July.

Some vaccine experts worry that even if a company intends to enroll those numbers, the Trump administration will prematurely approve their vaccines before their trials are over.

"I worry that a desperate White House could bring pressure on the FDA to approve something way before it's ready, just to be able to say, we promised you a vaccine and we got you one," Caplan said.

Dr. Paul Offit and Dr. Emanuel Ezekiel wrote an opinion piece Monday in The New York Times laying out the possibility that Trump will force the FDA to prematurely authorize a vaccine as an "October Surprise" to get votes.

"Given how this president has behaved, this incredibly dangerous scenario is not far-fetched," he said.

A former commander of the US Army Medical Research and Development Command told CNN that it "could be terrible" if politics got involved in the vaccine approval process.

"I trust the FDA won't roll over for politics, but there's always a possibility. Trump is not a very good scientist, to say the least," said Dr. Philip Russell, a retired major general who helped develop three vaccines.

Phase 3 trials vary in size

Phase 3 trials can vary in size. Offit's team at the University of Pennsylvania developed a rotavirus vaccine that went on the market in 2006, and those Phase 3 trials had about 70,000 study subjects, and trials for another rotavirus vaccine had 63,000 subjects.

Some other Phase 3 trials have been considerably smaller. Shingrix, a vaccine to prevent shingles, was approved after trials involving about 29,300 participants. Gardasil, a vaccine against the human papillomavirus, had Phase 3 studies of about 17,500 women.

So far, the federal government has agreed to fund Phase 3 studies of three experimental coronavirus vaccines: the University of Oxford/AstraZeneca, Moderna and Johnson & Johnson.

In addition, the federal government has given money for other Covid vaccine research efforts to Merck, Sanofi and Novavax.

CNN reached out to all six companies asking what size they planned for their Phase 3 trials.

Only Moderna and AstraZeneca responded with answers.

New York Coronavirus Cases

County data is updated nightly.

Cases: 628375

Reported Deaths: 34477
CountyCasesDeaths
Queens884967353
Kings873877498
Bronx627705028
Suffolk592732045
Nassau592382248
Westchester491021512
New York442183223
Erie23933785
Richmond222091126
Rockland21258692
Orange16555517
Monroe14338313
Onondaga10248222
Dutchess7021186
Albany5555148
Broome5201140
Oneida4655150
Niagara3599107
Ulster323898
Chemung295535
Putnam268264
Schenectady235357
Sullivan215648
Saratoga215120
Steuben171487
Rensselaer166651
Chautauqua151616
Oswego14366
Ontario125037
Tioga109549
Wayne108312
Cattaraugus105826
Tompkins10430
Columbia100556
Allegany98352
Cortland9792
Genesee9329
Madison89818
Cayuga8228
St. Lawrence7849
Greene67518
Livingston6719
Herkimer64512
Chenango62310
Orleans60457
Otsego5968
Warren57135
Wyoming5175
Jefferson5003
Fulton48428
Montgomery46616
Clinton4485
Washington44014
Lewis3459
Delaware3429
Schuyler2963
Essex27814
Seneca2765
Franklin2597
Yates2527
Schoharie1902
Hamilton421
Out of NY0120
Unassigned027
Utica
Clear
27° wxIcon
Hi: 43° Lo: 30°
Feels Like: 27°
Oneonta
Scattered Clouds
27° wxIcon
Hi: 41° Lo: 29°
Feels Like: 27°
Herkimer
Clear
27° wxIcon
Hi: 41° Lo: 31°
Feels Like: 27°
Thendara
Clear
27° wxIcon
Hi: 37° Lo: 30°
Feels Like: 27°
WKTV Radar
WKTV Temperatures
WKTV Severe Weather
Click here to learn more about A Healthier Mohawk Valley
Stuff the Bus Locations
Saluting Those Who Are Proud 2 Serve