Deerfield double-fatal shooting challenges prosecutors

The complex investigation into the double-fatal shooting of two attempted burglary suspects by a Deerfield homeowner continues to challenge prosecutors seeking to balance justice with a grieving family and justified homeowner.

Posted: May 31, 2019 6:09 PM

The complex investigation into the double-fatal shooting of two attempted burglary suspects by a Deerfield homeowner continues to challenge prosecutors seeking to balance justice with a grieving family and justified homeowner.

Oneida County District Attorney, Scott McNamara, says homeowner Ronald Stolarczyk isn't being held against his will in the Oneida County Jail for allegedly killing the two with an illegally-possessed handgun.

"The problem is, he does not want to be released at this point, because he doesn't have a home, his home was condemned," said McNamara, adding that Stolarczyk is also being treated for a potentially fatal leg infection.

McNamara points out that Stolarczyk didn't buy the gun illegally on the street in order to commit a crime with it; he failed to get a gun license and register his father's gun once his father died.

"No prior issues with him, no prior criminal behavior, he's a law abiding citizen minding his own business and put into a situation where he's forced to defend himself. This isn't the kind of guy that we're going to send to jail. I'm not even sure he'll end up with a criminal conviction on this," said McNamara.

The investigation is ongoing. Also still pending-what to do about the girlfriend of the deceased Nicholas Talerico. McNamara says she acknowledges driving Talerico and his aunt, Patricia Anne Talerico, to Stolarczyk's home on Tuesday. However, she is also providing valuable information to his office, which might help verify that the two killings were justified.

"At this point in time, that individual is cooperating with us, that individual has provided us with a lot of information, especially prior acts of Nicholas that do corroborate Mr. Stolarczyk's version that his house has previously been broken into and items taken. She also consented to us recovering numerous items," said McNamara. "I don't have any present intentions on charging her because we need her to cooperate and continue to cooperate with us when we have questions. If we charge her, we lose a witness and we lose her cooperation. Right now, I think it's important to get to the bottom of the two deaths, instead of concentrating on whether or not she's an accomplice to a burglary."

McNamara has the preliminary autopsy reports in the case, and says they corroborate what homeowner Stolarczyk said-that the two were coming at him when he shot them.

Stolarczyk is scheduled for a felony hearing in Deerfield Town Court Monday, but McNamara expects it will not take place.

New York Coronavirus Cases

County data is updated nightly.

Cases: 2066989

Reported Deaths: 52611
CountyCasesDeaths
Kings27515910235
Queens2723029785
Suffolk1983523365
Nassau1813753158
Bronx1801106498
New York1359564416
Westchester1283032262
Erie872971765
Richmond734501794
Monroe651661057
Orange47547810
Rockland46511952
Onondaga37558668
Dutchess28937442
Albany24270348
Oneida22021503
Niagara19398349
Broome18127355
Saratoga14924165
Ulster13638250
Schenectady12835195
Rensselaer11002140
Putnam1048891
Chautauqua8703140
Chemung7435134
Oswego732390
Ontario723492
Steuben6639143
Sullivan647272
St. Lawrence641596
Cayuga611292
Jefferson576766
Wayne554667
Cattaraugus546586
Genesee5286121
Herkimer5054107
Clinton475133
Madison441488
Fulton428190
Livingston425658
Tompkins419350
Montgomery4146121
Columbia3944101
Cortland367960
Tioga361861
Warren352957
Wyoming344951
Allegany335384
Chenango335376
Otsego335347
Greene329775
Washington302755
Orleans299283
Lewis260734
Franklin250312
Delaware229037
Seneca196256
Schoharie163216
Essex156326
Yates115626
Schuyler102614
Hamilton3042
Unassigned13458
Out of NY0231
Utica
Cloudy
42° wxIcon
Hi: 46° Lo: 40°
Feels Like: 39°
Oneonta
Cloudy
40° wxIcon
Hi: 43° Lo: 40°
Feels Like: 35°
Herkimer
Cloudy
42° wxIcon
Hi: 49° Lo: 42°
Feels Like: 39°
Old Forge
Cloudy
42° wxIcon
Hi: 44° Lo: 39°
Feels Like: 39°
WKTV Radar
WKTV Temperatures
WKTV Severe Weather
Looking for work or looking to hire? Check out the WKTV Job Fair!
Saluting Those Who Are Proud 2 Serve