Jury begins deliberating Conley's fate

Defense attorney Christopher Pelli delivered closing arguments first in the murder trial of Kaitlyn Conley, the Sauquoit woman accused of poisoning her boss, local chiropractor Mary Yoder, to death in July 2015.

Posted: Dec 1, 2017 5:29 PM

(May 12, 2017)

Defense attorney Christopher Pelli delivered closing arguments first in the murder trial of Kaitlyn Conley, the Sauquoit woman accused of poisoning her boss, local chiropractor Mary Yoder, to death in July 2015. Pelli began by questioning the strength of the prosecution's case.

"Proof beyond a reasonable doubt? Really? Really?" asked Pelli.

Prosecutor Laurie Lisi, too, addressed the subject of doubt, but in a very different way.

"Don't forget something philosophers have said throughout time. And that is, that there is some doubt in all that we do," offered Lisi.

Lisi also offered an answer to the question that's plagued many since the trial began three weeks ago: why?

"I submit to you, ladies and gentleman of the jury, that motive in this case comes down to two words: Adam Yoder," Lisi said. "Rejection did not sit well with Kaitlyn Conley ... Two times this defendant has been rejected by Adam Yoder. And we all know what can happen to a woman scorned. Hell hath no fury."

The defense said his client willingly submitted to police questioning six times without ever asking for an attorney.

"What guilty person goes to speak to police six separate times, doesn't ask for an attorney, and allows themselves to be subjected to every interrogation tactic in the book?" asked Pelli, who then told jurors to feel free to request to see and hear the recorded police interviews of Conley again. "If you want to watch them all ... In my opinion, it's a seven-hour documentary on how to obtain a false statement."

The prosecution let defendant Conley have the last word in her closing arguments, replaying a portion of Oneida County Sheriff's Department investigators' interview with Conley.

"Guys don't hang on to the murder weapon because that's why they get caught," said Investigator Mark VanNamee.

"Right, but guys also don't use poison," Conley said.

"A lot of people don't," VanNamee responded.

"They say it's a lady's weapon," Conley said.

Jurors sent the judge a note requesting to hear back three portions of testimony. They'll review them when they resume deliberations Friday morning at 9:30 a.m.

Also on Thursday, the judge released two alternate jurors and kept two.

New York Coronavirus Cases

County data is updated nightly.

Cases: 2519197

Reported Deaths: 56077
CountyCasesDeaths
Kings33356710845
Queens31512310287
Suffolk2391793601
Nassau2141533292
Bronx2075006750
New York1679194635
Westchester1435542340
Erie1061391945
Richmond888381935
Monroe840451184
Orange57452909
Rockland53047779
Onondaga51911760
Dutchess35563497
Albany30760389
Oneida28557586
Broome24353405
Niagara23976397
Saratoga20195199
Ulster17248278
Schenectady16673227
Rensselaer14761167
Putnam1246997
Chautauqua12379174
Oswego11622112
Chemung10862155
St. Lawrence10479126
Steuben10080173
Ontario9321110
Jefferson881475
Cayuga8640107
Sullivan844783
Wayne814084
Cattaraugus7678113
Genesee6983132
Herkimer6774128
Clinton667939
Tompkins649159
Fulton6296102
Madison6164102
Montgomery5940140
Livingston570171
Warren542884
Cortland532279
Tioga506171
Columbia4998111
Chenango467486
Washington458767
Allegany458496
Otsego456254
Greene437186
Wyoming437158
Orleans432087
Franklin425620
Lewis358638
Delaware354647
Seneca273363
Essex229231
Schoharie228921
Yates163128
Schuyler153217
Hamilton4363
Unassigned14628
Out of NY0313
Utica
Cloudy
58° wxIcon
Hi: 56° Lo: 49°
Feels Like: 58°
Oneonta
Cloudy
53° wxIcon
Hi: 58° Lo: 50°
Feels Like: 53°
Herkimer
Cloudy
58° wxIcon
Hi: 72° Lo: 50°
Feels Like: 58°
Old Forge
Cloudy
58° wxIcon
Hi: 55° Lo: 49°
Feels Like: 58°
WKTV Radar
WKTV Temperatures
WKTV Severe Weather
Game Day Deals - New Deals Each Week
Chapter Aesthetic October Giveaway
Cool To Be Kind 2021
Looking for work or looking to hire? Check out the WKTV Job Fair!
Saluting Those Who Are Proud 2 Serve